The Caffeinated Gear Team | December 20, 2024
Pour-over coffee brewing stands at the perfect intersection of art and science. As professional baristas and coffee experts, we’ve spent countless hours testing and comparing different pour-over coffee makers to bring you this comprehensive guide. While we’re calling this our “best of” list, we know that the perfect brewer depends entirely on your specific needs and preferences.
The beauty of pour-over coffee lies in its brilliant simplicity: hot water, fresh grounds, a filter, and gravity work together to create an exceptional cup. These manual brewers give you complete control over every aspect of the brewing process, from water temperature to pour speed, allowing you to craft coffee that matches your exact taste.
The story of pour-over coffee begins with an innovative woman named Melitta Bentz, who revolutionised coffee brewing in the early 1900s. Frustrated with the bitter taste and grounds in her coffee, she experimented until she created something brilliant: the paper coffee filter.
Melitta’s simple yet ingenious invention transformed home brewing. By placing blotting paper in a brass pot with holes, she created the first pour-over coffee maker – a design that would influence coffee brewing for generations to come.
Her company, Melitta, grew from a small family business into a global coffee brand, producing everything from filters to automatic coffee machines. But her original invention – the pour-over brewer – remains one of the most trusted methods for brewing exceptional coffee.
Need help keeping your Breville machine spotless? Watch this brilliant solution in action:
Today’s pour-over brewers maintain the elegant simplicity of Melitta’s original design while incorporating modern materials and refined brewing techniques. Whether you’re new to manual brewing or a seasoned enthusiast, we’ll help you find the perfect pour-over coffee maker for your needs.
Pour-over brewers come in two main categories, each suited to different brewing needs:
One-Piece Brewers: These combine the filter holder and carafe into a single unit. The iconic Chemex pioneered this design, originally created for both laboratory work and coffee brewing. They’re brilliant for brewing larger quantities and create a stunning centrepiece for any coffee station.
Single-Cup Brewers: These sit atop your favourite mug or server. Popular options like the Hario V60 and Kalita Wave excel at brewing one perfect cup at a time. They’re compact, portable, and ideal for exploring different coffee varieties.
The Chemex Classic stands as the original icon of one-piece brewers. Created by scientist Peter Schlumbohm in the 1940s, it rapidly gained popularity in prestigious stores like Wanamakers and Macy’s.
We’ve extensively tested all Chemex variants, and here’s what you need to know about each:
Chemex Classic: Despite its name, this isn’t the original version. It’s machine-made from high-quality borosilicate glass, offering excellent value while maintaining the iconic design. Available in 3-cup (16.7 oz), 6-cup (30 oz), 8-cup (40 oz), and 10-cup (50 oz) sizes.
Chemex Handblown: This is the true original design. Each piece is unique, with slightly thicker glass. While it won’t change your coffee’s taste, it offers unmatched craftsmanship. Sizes include 3-cup (16.7 oz), 5-cup (25 oz), 8-cup (40 oz), and 13-cup (65 oz).
Glass Handle Chemex: A practical variation that replaces the wooden collar with an integrated glass handle. Many of our team members prefer this design for its ease of use. Available in 3-cup (16.7 oz), 6-cup (30 oz), 8-cup (40 oz), and 10-cup (50 oz) sizes.
Bodum brings nearly 80 years of coffee expertise to this brewer. Founded in Copenhagen in 1944, this family-owned company earned its coffee credentials with the revolutionary Santos vacuum brewer in the late 1950s.
While often compared to the Chemex, Bodum’s pour-over maker charts its own course with a permanent stainless steel filter – a significant departure from traditional paper filters. This creates a distinct brewing profile that sits between classic pour-over and French press characteristics.
In our testing, we found the metal filter produces a fuller-bodied cup with more oils than paper-filtered coffee. For those who prefer a cleaner cup, Kalita filters fit perfectly inside the metal filter – offering welcome flexibility.
The Coffee Gator shares design similarities with the Bodum brewer but comes in at a more accessible price point. Available in 10.5 oz, 14 oz, and 27 oz sizes, it features a durable stainless steel mesh filter.
While newer to the market (established 2015), Coffee Gator has built a solid reputation. Our testing revealed consistently good results, though we noticed the mesh filter requires proper maintenance to prevent any flavour transfer between brews.
Remember to select your preferred size when ordering, as the default option is the smallest (10.5 oz). The larger sizes command a higher price but offer better value for households brewing multiple cups.
After thorough testing in our coffee lab, we discovered something rather special with this bundle. It’s not just a pour over coffee maker – you’re getting a complete set including a Gooseneck kettle. What caught our attention was the exceptional value, considering the inclusion of a quality gooseneck kettle that typically costs more than this entire set.
Mueller has built a solid reputation in kitchen appliances, so we weren’t surprised by the build quality. While the price might seem surprisingly competitive, our extensive testing confirmed this isn’t a case of “too good to be true” – the overwhelmingly positive user feedback matches our own experience.
The kettle deserves a quick mention, despite this being primarily a coffee maker review. Its gooseneck design offers precise pour control, letting you position the water flow exactly where you need it over your coffee grounds. The stainless steel construction provides rapid heating, which we confirmed in our temperature tests.
The brewer shares design similarities with Coffee Gator and Bodum models, featuring a reliable mesh filter system. We particularly liked the thoughtful addition of a silicone collar for safe handling. For those who prefer paper-filtered coffee, we found it fully compatible with Melitta type paper filters.
One point worth noting: while the brand is marketed as “Mueller Austria”, our research shows these are manufactured in China. This doesn’t impact performance but is worth mentioning for transparency.
Now, let’s explore single-cup pour over coffee makers. While these can actually brew multiple cups when paired with a server, their key distinction lies in the separate filter holder design. This allows for versatile brewing directly into a cup or larger server when using an appropriately sized filter.
A note about capacity ratings in this section: since these brewers work with various vessels, we’ll focus on the filter sizes they’re designed to accommodate and their practical brewing volumes.
Hario’s century-long legacy of glass craftsmanship (founded 1921 in Tokyo) makes it somewhat ironic that their most celebrated coffee brewer comes in plastic and ceramic variants. While glass versions exist, we’ve found the plastic and ceramic models consistently outperform in practical use.
The V60’s name stems from its precise 60-degree angle design (“vector 60”), and it’s become a cornerstone in professional coffee brewing. However, our testing reveals an important consideration: this isn’t a “set and forget” brewer. The V60 demands attention and technique, particularly in your pouring method.
For those seeking a more forgiving brew method, we’d recommend considering the Kalita (discussed below). But master the V60’s pour technique, and you’ll unlock exceptional coffee clarity and flavour control that few other brewers can match.
The bundle we’re featuring includes the Hario V60 #02 and matching server. Regarding capacity, here’s our practical brewing guide:
While the included server holds 20 oz / 600ml, we’ve found the #02 filter performs best with slightly smaller volumes. You can use smaller filters in larger V60s, but not vice versa.
Having extensively tested both ceramic and plastic versions, we actually prefer the plastic V60. It requires no pre-heating and proves more durable in daily use.
Another Japanese coffee innovation (Kalita began in Tokyo, 1958), this brewer takes a distinctly different approach from the V60. Our testing highlighted its flat-bottomed design with three drainage holes, contrasting with V60’s conical shape and single hole. This design difference proves crucial in practical use.
Where the V60 demands precise pouring technique, we found the Kalita Wave far more forgiving. You can simply add water and step away – we call this the “pour and leave” approach. The consistent extraction from the three-hole design means less dependency on pouring skill for great results.
Available in stainless steel (reviewed here), glass, and ceramic, the Wave comes in two sizes: 155 and 185. Through extensive testing, we’ve determined:
We’re reviewing the 185 stainless steel version as it’s proven most popular in our community. While the brewer itself performs excellently, we noticed occasional reports about rusting rivets on the handle. Our long-term testing suggests this might be batch-specific, as some units show no issues after years of use while others develop rust spots within months. Importantly, this doesn’t affect your coffee, as the filter prevents any contact with these parts.
While perhaps not as celebrated in specialty coffee circles as the V60 or Kalita, our testing revealed the Clever Dripper excels in a different category: foolproof brewing. Rather than requiring precise pouring techniques, this brewer focuses on two simple variables – ratio and steep time.
The process couldn’t be simpler: add filter, add coffee, pour water, wait, then place on your cup to release. This bundle includes both the essential coaster (for the steeping phase) and 100 filters to get you started.
Through our testing and community feedback, we’ve found this brewer particularly appeals to those seeking consistently good coffee without the learning curve of more technical brewers. It’s available in various colours beyond the standard option shown here.
Regarding dishwasher safety: our research reveals mixed guidance. While many users report successful dishwasher cleaning (particularly on the top rack), others note cosmetic changes after repeated washing. Without clear manufacturer specifications, we recommend gentle hand washing for longest life.
During our extensive testing process, we found this clever little brewer brings something unique to the pour-over world.
The standout feature is its innovative water tank system, which sits atop the brewer. Instead of the traditional continuous pour method, you simply add all your water at once and let the tank handle the rest. Perfect for those rushed morning brews when you need to multitask.
It’s compatible with standard cone-shaped filters, including Hario V60 options. While it does come with filters, you only get five in the box – a bit stingy, we must admit, and a common gripe among users.
As coffee specialists, we did notice one potential brewing physics issue. The single-hole conical design, combined with the tank-drip system, might not provide the most even extraction. Water distribution through the coffee bed could be slightly inconsistent, potentially affecting the final cup’s flavour profile. A flat-bottom, multi-hole design might have worked better with this concept.
However, we have to acknowledge that real-world results speak volumes – the overwhelming positive feedback from users suggests our theoretical concerns might be just that – theoretical.
Fellow has quickly earned our respect in the speciality coffee world. Since their 2013 Kickstarter launch by Jake Miller, they’ve consistently pushed the boundaries of coffee gear design.
What sets Fellow apart is their commitment to genuine innovation. In an industry often filled with copycat products, their unique approach to pour-over brewing, alongside their brilliant Gooseneck pour over kettle, demonstrates true creative thinking.
The Stagg comes in two variants: the XF (reviewed here) and the X. The XF model features a water tank system and accommodates larger brews up to 20 oz, while its sibling, the X, follows a traditional pour-over design for smaller 10 oz batches.
For brewing tips and detailed discussions about this device, we recommend checking out this thread on the home barista forums.
In our testing lab, this budget-friendly brewer surprised us with its thoughtful design choices. Similar to other one-piece pour-over makers, it features a built-in metal mesh filter, eliminating the need for paper filters. The 12-ounce capacity (marketed as 2-cup, though we’d call it a single generous serving) makes it perfect for solo brewing.
What impressed our team most was its single-layer mesh design. Unlike some competitors that use double-mesh systems prone to clogging, this simpler approach proves more effective and easier to maintain.
However, we should note that mesh filters produce a different cup profile than paper. Expect a fuller-bodied brew with more oils – some coffee lovers prefer this, others don’t. If you fancy a cleaner cup, standard Hario V60 filters (#01 or #02) fit perfectly.
Through our extensive testing, we’ve found each material has its sweet spot.
Plastic brewers offer the most consistent results with minimal fuss, as they don’t significantly affect water temperature. Other materials require slightly different approaches to achieve optimal extraction.
Glass and ceramic behave similarly – both need thorough preheating to prevent heat loss during brewing. Our testing shows these materials can produce excellent results, but proper temperature management is crucial.
Copper and stainless steel react differently – they heat quickly but also cool rapidly. Our advice? With metal brewers, start your pour immediately after preheating for best results.
For more technical details on this topic, check out this excellent article: How does your dripper material affect your pour over coffee?
Based on our extensive brewing experiments, we recommend starting with 50-60 grams of coffee per litre of water (that’s roughly 1.8-2 oz coffee to 34 fl oz water). For a standard 17 oz brew, use between 0.9-1 oz of coffee.
Remember, these are guidelines rather than rules. We encourage experimenting to find your perfect ratio.
This excellent video from James Hoffmann explains the concept brilliantly:
As coffee professionals, we find this question fascinating because it touches on several aspects of coffee brewing.
‘Strength’ in coffee can mean different things – body, flavour intensity, or technical measurements. Pour-over typically produces a lighter-bodied cup compared to other methods, which some might interpret as ‘weaker’.
Technically speaking, drip methods (both manual pour-over and electric) do tend to have lower Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) compared to other brewing methods. However, this doesn’t necessarily mean less flavour – often, it means better clarity and distinction of subtle taste notes.
For more insights into brewing methods, check out our comprehensive guide:
When brewing coffee with a paper filter, we consistently measure Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) between 1.2-1.5%, making it one of the lightest brewing methods available.
This means your paper-filtered coffee is roughly 98% water, which creates a distinctly different experience from French press brewing, which typically reaches 1.3-1.7% TDS.
Our testing shows that switching to a metal mesh filter significantly changes these characteristics.
This explains why some coffee enthusiasts describe mesh-filtered coffee as having a “muddy” taste – the higher TDS creates a fuller body that might not suit those who prefer the clean, crisp cup that paper filters deliver.
While adjusting your coffee-to-water ratio can enhance flavour intensity, it won’t increase the TDS reading.
This means pour-over coffee using paper filters will always maintain its characteristic light mouthfeel compared to other brewing methods.
Through our extensive testing, we’ve found that defining “stronger” is crucial for achieving your ideal cup.
If you’re seeking a fuller mouthfeel, we recommend trying a metal mesh filter.
This method creates a body that sits between traditional drip and French press coffee.
For those wanting more intense flavours, we suggest experimenting with your brew ratio, grind size, and extraction parameters.
Interestingly, using more coffee doesn’t always equal better taste.
In our experience, sometimes reducing the coffee-to-water ratio actually highlights subtle flavour notes more effectively.
During our coffee tastings, we’ve noticed that “strength” isn’t always the real issue.
Sometimes, when coffee doesn’t quite hit the spot, it’s not about strength at all – it might be the acidity level or specific flavour notes that don’t match your preferences.
Without formal training as Q graders (professional coffee tasters), it can be challenging to pinpoint exactly what’s missing from your cup.
We’ve found that exploring different coffee varieties is often the best way to discover what truly suits your palate.
While taste preferences are subjective, our first recommendation for addressing watery coffee is adjusting your coffee-to-water ratio.
Based on our brewing experiments, we recommend starting with 14 grams (about half an ounce) of ground coffee for every 240ml (8 oz) of water.
From there, you can adjust to match your taste preferences.
Blooming involves saturating your ground coffee with just enough water to cover the grounds, allowing CO2 to release before continuing with the main brew.
Through our testing of various methods, we’ve found that bloom times and water volumes can significantly impact different coffees.
We recommend experimenting with different recipes based on your coffee’s origin, processing method, and roast profile.
Pour-over coffee’s distinctiveness lies in its characteristically lighter body, which comes from its lower percentage of total dissolved solids.
Notably, paper-filtered pour-over coffee contains lower levels of cafestol and kahweol compared to other brewing methods.
While we won’t delve too deeply into these compounds here, they’re particularly interesting regarding coffee’s health implications.
Our research into these compounds revealed some fascinating contradictions.
Some studies suggest these compounds contribute to coffee’s health benefits, while others link cafestol to increased cholesterol levels.
While we’re coffee experts rather than medical professionals, our research suggests that those monitoring their cholesterol might want to consider paper-filtered pour-over coffee to reduce cafestol intake.
As coffee professionals, we believe each brewing method has its merits.
Pour-over often appeals to those who prefer a cleaner cup compared to French press, with virtually no risk of grounds in your cup.
When compared to electric drip makers, pour-over offers superior control over brewing variables, often at a fraction of the cost.
Regarding pour-over versus espresso, they’re quite different experiences.
Pour-over provides a gentler intensity and lighter body, making it perfect for those who prefer a more subtle coffee experience – and it’s significantly more affordable than investing in an espresso machine!
Caffeinatedgear.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.co.uk.
© 2025 Caffeinated Gear.